Hacker News Reader

Comment by self_awareness | Hacker News Reader

As a non-American, I'm just wondering, why won't you help these people get legal citizenship status since it's clear as day most people want them in?

Why won't you protest against current citizenship rules, since it's clear you want them to be changed?

edit: I see it's just a simple "f** ice" and "you need to go" case. I'll show myself out

View on HN

It’s not just a simple case it’s an extremely contentious issue the country is deeply divided on based on location and political leanings.

> since it's clear as day most people want them in?

Not sure how you concluded this. Particularly for unskilled labour.

Well if ICE deports illegal immigrants, and you're anti-ICE, then you do want those illegal immigrants? Or how is this supposed to work?

> if ICE deports illegal immigrants, and you're anti-ICE, then you do want immigrants?

No. I’m anti-murder.

This logic is like saying someone who objects to the Nazis is racist against Germans.

So you want to deport, but someone else than ICE should do it?

Also, to be fair, nazis were Germans. Not aliens from outer space. Those were german people who identified with NSDAP party.

Edit: I understand (well, kind of...) why people downvote me, but I'm really lost when trying to understand why they downvote you. I don't think I'll ever understand what's going on.

> you want to deport, but someone else than ICE should do it?

I want it to be done without murder. Murder is bad.

I don’t care if it’s done by ICE or the Pink Pony Friendly Airlift Service. They should do it per the law. They should not have to blow hundreds of thousands of dollars per deportation. And they should do it without murder, with murderers in their ranks being charged per the law.

> to be fair, nazis were Germans

…yes. That doesn’t make being anti-Nazi racist against Germans.

It’s an easy conclusion to come to if your only view of the US comes from moderated online spaces and the news media.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com