Comment by dceddia | Hacker News Reader

Comment by dceddia | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

So I’m probably in a similar spot - I mostly prompt-and-check, unless it’s a throwaway script or something, and even then I give it a quick glance.

One thing that stands out in your steps and that I’ve noticed myself- yeah, by prompt 10, it starts to suck. If it ever hits “compaction” then that’s beyond the point of return.

I still find myself slipping into this trap sometimes because I’m just in the flow of getting good results (until it nosedives), but the better strategy is to do a small unit of work per session. It keeps the context small and that keeps the model smarter.

“Ralph” is one way to do this. (decent intro here: https://www.aihero.dev/getting-started-with-ralph)

Another way is “Write out what we did to PROGRESS.md” - then start new session - then “Read @PROGRESS.md and do X”

Just playing around with ways to split up the work into smaller tasks basically, and crucially, not doing all of those small tasks in one long chat.

I will check out Ralph (thank you for that link!).

> Another way is “Write out what we did to PROGRESS.md” - then start new session - then “Read @PROGRESS.md and do X”

I agree on small context and if I hit "compacting" I've normally gone too far. I'm a huge fan of `/clear`-ing regularly or `/compact <Here is what you should remember for the next task we will work on>` and I've also tried "TODO.md"-style tracking.

I'm conflicted on TODO.md-style tracking because in practice I've had an agent work through everyone on the list, confidently telling me steps are done, only to find that's not the case when I check its work. Either a TODO.md that I created or one I had the agent create both suffer from this. Also, getting it update the TODO.md has been frustrating, even when I add it to CLAUDE.md "Make sure to mark tasks as complete in the TODO.md as you finish them" or adding the same message to the end of all my prompts, it won't always update it.

I've been interested in trying out beads to see if works better than a markdown TODO file but I haven't played with that yet.

But overall I agree with you, smaller chunks are key to success.

I hate TODO.mds too. If I ever have to use one, I'll keep track of it manually, and split the work myself into chunks of the size I believe CC/codex can handle. TODO.md is a recipe for failure because you'll quickly have more code than you can review and nothing to trust that it was executed well.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com