Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by steveklabnik | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

steveklabnik

Here's the discussion from back in the day when this changed: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=837698

In practice, people generally didn't even vote with two options, they voted with one!

IIRC youtube did even get rid of downvotes for a while, as they were mostly used for brigading.

View on HN

> IIRC youtube did even get rid of downvotes for a while, as they were mostly used for brigading.

No, they got rid of them most likely because advertisers complained that when they dropped some flop they got negative press from media going "lmao 90% dislike rate on new trailer of <X>".

Stuff disliked to oblivion was either just straight out bad, wrong (in case of just bad tutorials/info) and brigading was very tiny percentage of it.

YouTube never got rid of downvotes they just hid the count. Channel admins can still see it and it still affects the algorithm

Oh, didn't they remove the dislike count after people absolutely annihilated one of their yearly rewind with dislikes?

The original sin is argued to be the Youtube Rewind 2018. But it took them until 2021 to roll it out.

well, people annihilated every of their rewinds with dislikes. But yeah, that might've contributed.

It was removed after some presidential speeches attracted heavy dislikes.

Youtube always kept downvotes and the 'dislike' button, the change (which still applies today) was that they stopped displaying the downvote count to users - the button never went away though.

Visit a youtube video today, you can still upvote and downvote with the exact same thumbs up or down, the site however only displays to you the count of upvotes. The channel owners/admins can still see the downvote count and the downvotes presumably still inform YouTube's algorithms.

There is also an independent "Return Youtube Dislike" browser extension that shows the dislike numbers. It's very convenient.

That doesn't show the real number, only "a combination of scraped dislike stats and estimates extrapolated from extension user data."

I think that just the absence in official app and the existence of this tool makes this point largely irrelevant. Company in question could easily reverse this decision overnight as the data exist, but absent that people adjust to an available proxy estimate. It is interesting though, because it shows clear intent of "we don't want to show actual sentiment".

The official youtube stats (views, comments, upvotes) are not real/real-time either. But that's the best we have. And dislike numbers are in the same universe of credibility and closeness to reality. It's definitely good enough.

If you want downvote data be more precise, do your part and install the extension! :-)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com