Hacker News Reader

Comment by RockieYang | Hacker News Reader

CSS is tricky, touch one place the whole thing could collapse. I guess that just the nature. I find this course is very helpful for me https://css-for-js.dev/

View on HN

That’s just bad code in general. In any language, when incompetent or very inexperienced devs write code, they tend to write brittle code that breaks entirely when one thing changes. CSS is not unique. It’s just that a lot of people wrote CSS without really learning it, so they wrote it incompetently.

Language design has a lot to do with it. CSS encourages much more global mutable state than even something like C, so of course it's going to be brittle in practice. The solution is writing the least amount of CSS possible and then just using components to build up a UI. Using CSS any other way feels patently insane.

I think this is best evidenced by our constant innovation of news ways to undermine the "cascading" part of CSS and introducing scope wherever possible.

The brittleness of badly written CSS is unrelated to its cascading nature. In my experience the “cascading” part is a good thing. If you want to make a paragraph red, you do want all other inline elements inside the paragraph to be red as well. Also, in my experience, most of the brittleness comes from an insufficient understanding of selector specificity, including both unintentionally broad selectors as well as unintentionally narrow selectors.

The solution is a careful consideration of scoping: most programming languages encourage the developer to carefully consider whether a variable should be local and global, and a similar amount of care must be taken in CSS too. The programmer needs to have a high awareness of which rules should apply to the whole document and which should apply to this particular component.

> touch one place the whole thing could collapse

That's one very strong indicator that you are doing it wrong.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com