Hacker News Reader

Comment by Etheryte | Hacker News Reader

This is neat, but I'm not really convinced this level of granularity makes sense for personal finances? Or at least it does not for me personally. I find that simply entering all my accounts into one big excel once a month more than suffices to keep track of everything. Maybe I make a typo here and there but it doesn't really matter in the grand scheme of things cuz I'm gonna type a new number next month anyway.

View on HN

I guess it depends on the complexity of ones personal finances? The author had multiple currencies, investments, and who knows what else.

I ran a small business for a while, and I would draw a parallel to that. Once a family's finances hits the complexities of a small business, multiple assets, loans, cars, long term savings, investments, I'd say the granularity is worth it. I would certainly like to try it out.

I tick all the boxes you listed after having worked in a handful of different countries, but personally I don't really see the value add. My bank shows an overview in my main currency of choice and so do brokerage accounts. Perhaps to turn the question around, what value do you get out of it for personal finances? I wouldn't really compare to a business too closely since understanding all of your input costs down to a fine level is much more important there, at least in my opinion. The price of flour doesn't matter too much to the cent when you buy a bag every now and then, but it matters a lot when you're buying in tons.

I used to use an application in France which automatically sorted all my expenses - it sadly doesn't work as well anymore.

I have to say seeing some macro-budget category summed on a year and seeing how much of my money they consume was quite useful just to recalibrate. It wasn't life changing but it triggered things like: am I really ok spending that much on restaurants?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com