Comment by hirako2000 | Hacker News Reader

Comment by hirako2000 | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

To some it felt like nothing as they couldn't render the content.

The challenge when tackling difficult problems is to bring in solutions to those problems.

Subway offered an alternative to junk food. By offering custom flavors of choice, giving consumers more control over what they eat. I don't see any fresh food at subway. Does it mean what they did is futile? No. Can't we point out this is another type of junk ? We better do.

The site is wonderful when rendered with JavaScript. A web to aspire to is one where the system font is set by default, at least could be chosen.

All valid concerns looking at an endeavor discussing a better web. The author may even take note and iterate, there was no claim it was definitive work.

One of the most frustrating and perhaps thought-terminating clichés on the internet and social media at large is alluded to in this reply:

“I personally could not view this page [because I turned off JS], therefore I will dismiss it out of hand as it didn’t cater to my needs.” A choice made by the consumer somehow makes the author accountable for it.

Or more succinctly, “but what about me [or people I’ve anointed myself as spokesperson for]?”spoken by someone not the intended audience for the piece, trying to make the author responsible for their need.

The answer to which, I think, is either, “it’s not for you then so move on,” or perhaps even “misery is optional, just enable JS ffs.”

The idea that the creator of a work must bend to the will of those that consume it seems to be highly prevalent, and is pretty much at odds with creativity itself.

I have found that HN is, ironically, a horrible place to post experimental work on, with a few exceptions - e.g. things "written in Rust" etc. I think it's because the majority of the commentators here haven't really made anything from scratch.

I'm going to have to bite at the bait here: your post is guilty of what it's critiquing, and to a larger degree than the post being replied to.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com