Hacker News Reader

Perhaps the thing I hate most about Tahoe is the embedded rounded rectangle around the menu inside of the larger rounded rectangle window. They're trying to go for this look of a menu floating above the rest of the window it belongs to, but it just looks sloppy to me in dark mode.

View on HN

Looks sloppy in any mode. The amount of wasted space has gone from “well a little bit of rounding/padding is alright to achieve a unified unique look” to “holy shit this is just Fischer price laugh and learn garbage”.

1/2 pixel strips everywhere, around tons of elements. Huge rounded corners. Slow showy animations.

This isn’t a UI for adults, this is a UI for a fake computer sequence in a cheap Netflix movie.

Even Jony Ive, who I thought was a bad UI designer when that job was unwisely given to him, thinks Alan Dye has no taste. That’s saying something.

Personally I couldn’t get past the horrible gray squircle jails for icons that don’t adhere to their boring new standard. They didn’t even update the pixelmator icon for quite a while, which they themselves acquired. Shows you how much effort went in to this.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com