Again, I'm not concerned for new writes, I'm concerned for all existing data from the previous months and years.
And getting in this situation only takes one out of a wide outage or a bad push that takes down the cluster. Even if that's stupid, it's a common enough stupid that you should never risk your data on the certainty you won't make that mistake.
You can't protect against everything, but you should definitely protect against unclean shutdown.
Also, garage gives you the possibility to automatically snapshot the metadata, advices on how to do the snapshotting at the filesystem level and to restore that.
How do filesystem level snapshots work if nodes might get corrupted by power loss? Booting from a snapshot looks exactly the same to a node as booting from a power loss event. Are you implying that it does always recover from power loss and you're defending a flaw it doesn't even have?