Hacker News Reader

Comment by lm28469 | Hacker News Reader

Sarkozy is out because in France you're free until proven guilty, unless you represent a risk to society or have a high risk of fleeing, neither apply to him, hence he's free until the final verdict

View on HN

The other poster said sarkozy was sentenced to 5 years. How was that not the result of having been found guilty? I understand there are more trials to follow but do not see why that would free him.

Because you can appeal a decision, and a verdict isn't final until every legal options have been pursued, appeal being one of them

It's simple really, but if course it's not as outrageous and can't be used as rage bait

Wait, in France the sentencing is done before trial? Why would he already be sentenced to 5 years without first being tried or convicted?

There was a special law (that his party voted for btw) that added sentencing enhancements for the specific crime he did iirc

It's surprisingly often the case that criminals assume everyone else is doing what they're doing, and want harsh punishments for it.

(see also: the rates of homosexuality among homophobes)

No, he was convicted, put in prison, appealed the verdict and was released after 20 days waiting for the next trial

You can appeal, and until every legal options have been pursued a verdict is not final. Since you're innocent until proven guilty, and you cannot be guilty untill all options have been pursued, you're free until the appeal has been completed.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com