Hacker News Reader

Hacker News

Comment by JimDabell | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

JimDabell

How about following the precedent of all of these users of /.well-known/

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Well-known_URI#List_of_well-kn...

robots.txt was created three decades ago, when we didn’t know any better.

Moving llms.txt to /.well-known/ is literally issue #2 for llms.txt

https://github.com/AnswerDotAI/llms-txt/issues/2

Please stop polluting the web.

View on HN

I prioritize simplicity and adoption for non-technical users over strict IETF compliance right now. My goal is to make this work for a shop owner on Shopify and Wix, not just for sysadmins.

That said, I am open to supporting .well-known as a secondary location in v1.1 if the community wants it.

How is using a standard path 'just for sysadmins' again? You are introducing something new today.

Try uploading a file to /.well-known/ on Shopify or Wix. You cannot. Their file managers block hidden directories (starting with a dot). To do it, you need a custom app, a meta-field hack, or a reverse proxy. That is sysadmin work. Uploading a file to the root is user work. That is the difference.

So the solution is that both Shopify and Wix should let the user edit those files. That's it.

Agreed. In a perfect world, they would. But I cannot merge PRs into Shopify's core. Waiting for trillion-dollar corporations to change their security models is a death sentence for a new protocol. We build for the infrastructure that exists today, not the one we wish for. When they open the gates, we will move. Until then, we live in the root.

How are comments handled on proposals? Are you the final authority on the standard or is there some community consensus?

I am the initiator, not the dictator. Governance is defined in Section 13: Contributing & Governance. Decisions are made by consensus of the Working Group. Right now, we are bootstrapping. I make the initial calls to ship v1.0, but the roadmap involves the community. I invite you to open an Issue.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com