Hacker News Reader

Comment by robinhood | Hacker News Reader

Clearly you haven't used something like HTMX. Do you understand what "returning HTML by the server" mean? You are basically sending back a view, like you would in any other framework actually. This would be the exact same pattern as displaying or dynamically adding a new component from either React or Vue. It doesn't create any styling issue at all, nor any unintended consequences.

View on HN

I’ve used jquery which is very heavy into html fragments. It can get unwieldy compared to keeping all your rending logic in one place and applying data to it like in React. Other comments here validate the suspicion that HTMX can fall apart in large systems.

Unless you’re saying the components returned by HTMX are using the shadow dom for isolation, you can very easily run into styling problems by changing a style and not realizing some injected fragment of HTML somewhere relies on it being a certain way. I hope you’re using a monorepo because unlike typescript APIs, those HTML fragments and CSS styles are not type checked.

Well yeah, HTMX wouldn't be a good fit for micro-frontends, but I didn't think many people were actually using those. You have to write all your html in accordance with a single stylesheet, but that strikes me as the least of HTMX's impositions.

That's because jquery takes a very global approach to the DOM, which will naturally lead to spaghetti code.

Every backend framework, be it dotnet or Symphony or Rails, has a concept of components. It's a non-issue.

This is easy to solve. Just configure htmx to automatically add an `Accept-Version` header to its requests:

    document.addEventListener('htmx:configRequest', evt => {
      evt.detail.headers['Accept-Version'] = APP_VERSION;
    });

And have a middleware that checks for this header. If it finds a version mismatch, have it respond with an HTTP 400 and a message to update the app to get the latest version. This is pretty similar to what many SPAs are already doing nowadays so it shouldn't come as a big surprise.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com