This response answers too much--why did we invent and adopt tar for all other use cases, then? Why do we not still use ar for its original general archiving purpose in any other situation but this one? Obviously there is some reason! I'm curious what that reason is. You can make regular archives with ar today but we don't--"it still works" wasn't good enough reason for any other archive use case. What are the general archiving requirements that don't exist for object archives that meant ar is still fine for this one use case?