So there's some strange sense in which these laws of nature seem to arise from, or are at least deeply connected to geometry.
So there's some strange sense in which these laws of nature seem to arise from, or are at least deeply connected to geometry.
Thanks for the postclassical angle on this, I missed that in the comment below, which was only "charge"
Not sure what you mean by Hodge equation, care to elaborate?
I assume (for the lay physicist) it's the Hodge decomposition mentioned in here (pp6-8)
To be fair and looking back at history, the discovery of Maxwell equations, relativity and quantum theory are so intertwined with the discovery, invention and application of new Mathematical ideas, in particular emanating from the work of Hamilton, Grassmann and then Lie, Levi-Civita, Cartan, etc. that is difficult to separate at what extent those concepts influenced over each other in their attempt to explain and describe reality. The ability to express Maxwell equations in a compact form with quaternions before vector calculus was even a thing provides some evidence. One can argue that the classical formulation for electromagnetism could be expressed that way because Hamilton was trying to find the proper framework that could capture his ideas about physics. Fast forward some 60 years and you also have a similar thing happening with Pauli matrices in quantum theory, and the work of Noether in modern physics.
It is fantastically long, but still fascinating !
Charge is conserved => symmetry (though not capturing exactly the "(non-Noetherian) localization" that is special to it)
GP suggested the opposite thought process-- as you rightly imply:
disagreement between 2 observers whether charge is conserved or not => discovering that _something else_ is conserved
Alternativey, geometry is how we choose to formulate our understanding of the Universe's behavior.
Some also think of this additional Lie as a ("central") extension of the Galilei group?
https://physics.stackexchange.com/questions/281485/how-did-m...
(Sorry, couldnot get Gemini to give a ref for that)
Update: better ref, but paywalled
https://pubs.aip.org/aapt/ajp/article-abstract/48/1/5/235124...