Hacker News Reader

Comment by smt88 | Hacker News Reader

Meta is only rolling this out in Europe. This does nothing to shake their alarming monopolies in places like India.

I see no reason why none of all those extremely talented developers that America desperately needs can't come up with a messaging service of their own.

I guess it is more about captured user base than the technology.

What other differentiating factors can you implement that can steer the masses from one messaging platform to the other. I cannot think of any.

They can and they have. It's the lock-in Meta is imposing that's preventing new options to succeed in the market.

If you have said this about Apple/Google, I would have said ... maaaaaayyybeeeeee ...

But in this case, how exactly does Meta prevent people from India downloading and using another messaging app?

Nothing. It's a monopoly in a market that is heavily network dependent. Without interoperability, it's infeasible for a new option to become viable. Though I'm sure you know this already and just believe that monopolies are alright for consumers.

What would you believe is a solution?

WhatsApp is the core of Indian society. It's used by the government, all businesses, and everyone with a smartphone. It's used for payments, customer service, scheduling doctor's appointments, etc. You literally cannot replace it with something else anymore.

Well the Indian government can consider a law similar to the EU Digital Market Acts that enforces such behaviour.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com