Hacker News Reader

Comment by pixel_popping | Hacker News Reader

this is too naive sorry, Hetzner will disconnect (and ban you if DDoS is too long), same as OVH. It works mostly for brutal UDP flooding but sophisticated attacks such as swarm of Puppeteers hosted on infected machines by the millions will not be protected, those "new DDoS mode" are offered by most DDoS providers.

View on HN

Cloudflare will disconnect you from their free plan just as quickly.

Especially when you are facing "infected machines by the millions".

Except that Cloudflare is geared towards ddos protection - i.e. you can monitor, get alerts, turn on temporary protection, etc. It can do this because that's it's main business. It's not possible to have the same expectations from infra providers like Hetzner.

I don't think Cloudflare's main business is DDoS protection.

Likely true, but now you can go back to the original statement: the issue isn't really that the service isn't available for a while... It's that the hoster will remove your server.

Your server will keep existing if cloudflare just drops their free service, effectively going down for the ddosrs but still available for your own access directly

Citation needed. I know folks using the free plan that have gotten ddos’d and cloudflare kept them online. Can you point me to an article where cloudflare disconnected someone for getting attacked

They definitely used to do this ca. 2011-2012, any bigger attack and they'd drop you right away if you were on a free plan (and slightly slower if you weren't). But well, that was almost 15 years ago.

evidence?

Handled hundred of dedicated servers for different projects over the last 20 years. Yes, OVH literally does ban accounts, and Hetzner nullroute your service at first if it's an elaborated attack.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com