Hacker News Reader

Comment by xyzzy123 | Hacker News Reader

I actually like terraform for its LACK of power (tho yeah these days when I have a choice I use a lot of small states and orchestrate with tg).

Pulumi or CDK are for sure more powerful (and great tools) but when I need to reach for them I also worry that the infra might be getting too complex.

View on HN

IMO Pulumi and CDK are an opportunity to simplify your infra by capturing what you’re working with using higher-level abstractions and by allowing you to refactor and extract reusable pieces at any level. You can drive infra definitions easily from typed data structures, you can add conditionals using natural language syntax, and stop trying to program in a configuration language (Terraform HCL with surprises like non-short-circuited AND evaluation).

You still end up having IaaC. You can still have a declarative infrastructure.

Absolutely, the best case is it's much better, safer, readable etc. However, the worst case is also worse. From the perspective of someone who provides devops support to multiple teams, terraform is more "predictable".

That's how we use CDK. Our CDK (in general) creates CloudFormation which we then deploy. As far as the tooling which we have for IaC is concerned, it's indistinguishable from hand-written CloudFormation — but we're able to declare our intent at a higher level of abstraction.

> and stop trying to program in a configuration language

Many people don't program with a configuration language like HCL. We use it as what it is - a DSL - that covers its main use case in an elegant manner. Maybe I never touched complex enough infra that twists a DSL into a general-use language, but in my experience there are simply no real benefits when using something like CDK (I never tried Pulumi to be fair).

Agreed, it is much too easy to fall into bad habits. The whole goal of OpenTofu is declarative infrastructure. With CDK and pulumi, it's very easy to end up in a place where you lose that.

But if you need to do something in a particular way, the tools should never be an obstacle.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com