So if you claim that something is equivalent to it, you better be prepared to define what exactly "something" is, and give a rigorous argument as to why it's equivalent. Some hand-waving with vaguely defined and ambiguous terms just doesn't cut it.
The definition of an efficient market actually means that that the price of a security at time T represents all that market players can deduce about its history by time T, using information travel and processing speeds that market players possess. It really just means that everything that is historically known about the security can and will be used to determine its price as fast as possible. If it isn't possible - it won't determine the price.
But you do assume that I don't know these other types of knowledge when in fact I do.
Your open mind argument can be applied to spiritual and alternative medicine just as well - all knowledge is not equal.