Comment by madaxe_again | Hacker News Reader

Comment by madaxe_again | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

Apparently very popular content - a parent at my kid’s kindergarten wanted to make cake for their kids birthday, said they’d only use 1 tsp of honey in the whole thing.

Cue universal freak out in the parents’ WhatsApp group.

Apparently, sugar:

  - causes cancer
  - causes autism
  - causes hyperactivity
  - causes blindness
  - makes children indolent and lazy
  - will permanently ruin a child if they even look at it

It’s weird, IMO. I let my kiddo have sugar within reason, and somehow she’s leaner than any of the other kids in her class, who even already have rotten teeth at two, despite their sugar free diets. They feed them simple carbs almost exclusively, and are oblivious to amylase.

Perhaps it’s because she’s physically active - the rest of her cohort are pretty much forbidden from walking or running as those pose risks, and children must be sheltered from all conceivable risk so that they grow up into independent and capable adults.

I would argue that that - physical activity - is far more important than what you shove in your face.

There have been repeatedly, credibly and demonstrably shown to be significant benefits to not spending your entire life sitting on your ass - but I guess it’s harder to get off your ass than to proselytise about sugar being an evil and artificial harmful chemical that has no place in the human body - despite it literally being what we run off of.

"I would argue that that - physical activity - is far more important than what you shove in your face."

No, it bloody is not.

I used to drive a bicycle for 6 - 12 hours ever day while working in the delivery. I also didn't watch what I was eating.

I ended up getting fat and with haemorrhoids. So I had to quit cycling.

Then I spend some time (years actually) researching and slowly improving my diet.

Result? I lost weight, my haemorrhoids (and several other health issues) stopped acting up, and I am overall much healthier despite most of my physical activity being walking.

Yes, exercise is important. But it won't help you if you eat massive amounts of garbage food.

So stop talking stuff you have no clue about.

Also, we do not "run off of" sugar. Human body can run off sugar, or fat, or a combination of these. And argument could be made that running off fat is actually healthier. Body can in fact produce all sugar it needs with absolutely zero need for dietary sugar (note that doesn't mean you should go zero carb, just that carbs / sugars are not a metabolic necessity).

As for this: "who even already have rotten teeth at two, despite their sugar free diets. They feed them simple carbs almost exclusively, and are oblivious to amylase."

Uhh... carbs ARE sugars. It literally doesn't matter that you are avoiding "sugar" if you end up eating bread instead.

Sugars are carbohydrates. Carbohydrates are not sugars.

"A carbohydrate (/ˌkɑːrboʊˈhaɪdreɪt/) is a sugar"

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbohydrate

“Or a sugar derivative”

Great selective quoting. 10/10.

Moderate exercising is conaistently shown to improve peoples health results. Study after study, it has positive impact.

It may or may not affect peoples weight (which is aesthetic issue on itself), but in terms of health improvements it is one intervention that consistently works.

They are not saying kids should be 8 hours on bikes whether they feel like or not. They are saying they should run around with other kids which something entirely different.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com