Hacker News Reader

HNHacker News

Top New Best Ask Show Jobs

Comment by gizajob | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

gizajob·

What does U(1) symmetry in gauge theory arise from?

View on HN

It's turtles all the way down.

Not from bribes and/or moving faster than the regulators. Altman's projects, on the other hand...

At some point the answer is “because that’s what reality is.”

If by "reality" you mean "the universe", then the way the universe is depends on a cause, as the existence of the universe is not explained by the universe itself (even an "eternal" universe). Its existence is contingent on some other cause that ultimately cannot be contingent and thus does not require explanation.

So the cause or dare I say reason for the universe being the way it is will depend on its cause.

The universe just is that way because it is. THAT is the root cause.

That's not a cause. That's a tautological assertion that obscured by the use of the word "because".

And you have an implied axiomatic assertion that everything must have a cause, even though that necessarily results in an infinite recursion of cause-finding.

Nowhere did I say or imply everything needs a cause. That's your baggage. In fact, it is the exact opposite: that because an infinite regress is incoherent and impossible, there must be some necessary uncaused cause where the buck stops.

"The universe" cannot be that cause, as the universe and everything in it is contingent.

I feel like the language of this argument is self-undermining. The existence of the universe being dependent on a cause that is itself not contingent on anything else… As easily the existence of the universe could be not contingent with anything else.

> As easily the existence of the universe could be not contingent with anything else.

But the universe is contingent. It isn't necessary. It is one big chain of dependence.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com