As far as sentience is concerned, we can't say they aren't sentient because we don't know the computational structures these models realize, nor do we know the computational structures required for sentience.
As far as sentience is concerned, we can't say they aren't sentient because we don't know the computational structures these models realize, nor do we know the computational structures required for sentience.
The inference software that would normally read from that file is also not alive, as it's literally very concise code that we wrote to traverse through that file.
So if the disk isn't alive, the file on it isn't alive, the inference software is not alive - then what are you saying is alive and thinking?
“So if the severed head isn’t alive, the disembodied heart isn’t alive, the jar of blood we drained out isn’t alive - then what are you saying is alive and thinking?”
- Some silicon alien life forms somewhere debating whether the human life form they just disassembled could ever be alive and thinking