Why I love my Boox Palma e-reader | Hacker News Reader

Why I love my Boox Palma e-reader

minimal.bearblog.dev

99 pointspastel558 comments

I'd not heard of this model, and amusingly my first hit (4th in an incognito) for `Boox Palma` is a lengthy reddit-user rant from 2y ago about build quality, sluggish performance, and woeful battery life.

That aside, totally agree on the form factor. My first ebook reader was a pocketbook 360, which came bundled with a rigid cover (would snap onto the back while reading) and a 5" screen, when most ebook readers were around the 6" diagonal.

The size delta was significant as it meant the difference between fitting in a jacket pocket vs needing to carry a bag, and that really changes your likelihood to take it with you / read a book.

It's a great device and actually pretty fast- reddit is just a place for people to moan and groan and not provide anything constructive now.

And its actually quite hard to get now as it has been replaced by Palma 2 which is even faster. You can actually watch youtube videos on it and it is better than one would expect.

There isn't a single product on this world where top hits wouldn't be random reddit rants over them.

I take the opposite view about size. I am already carrying a phone which is acceptable for reading on (or TTS to my headphones). If I expect to have the chance to read at length then I am willing to pack a larger ereader.

I recently went with a Kobo Libra Color to replace my aging 10th gen Kindle. It’s a nice device, and the stock Kobo software is fine. The best part though is how well koreader runs on it (much more seamless than koreader on Kindle).

The killer features of koreader for me are sane PDF scaling/reflowing, the ability to handle large PDFs, and multiple export formats for annotations.

I am on the fence between Libra and Clara (smaller than Libra). What do you recommend? Do you wish you had gone with a smaller version? Weight, easy to hold etc.

Price difference is negligible but I am confused by the size difference and ease of use

I have a previous-generation Clara and quite like it. It's easy to slip into a pocket and bring with me wherever I go. The only thing I miss is physical buttons to turn the page.

One day I'll pick up one of the larger versions for home use, though.

I have Clara BW and Libra Color.

Clara: - Small form factor. Super convenient to read and bring it anywhere. - No issue to read any materials imo.

Libra: - It's slightly bigger and heavier. - I find it easier to read books with lots of graph, images since it's bigger. - I can also read comics with color. Pretty awesome.

Imo, boils down to your preference, hand size (I'm not a big guy). I like both devices. Libra main advantage to me is just color. Size is personal preference. If there's any store nearby, I'd suggest to just go and try it out first (or any ebook with similar size).

Make sure you understand the tradeoffs of color screen. I found it to be significantly less pleasant for reading. It's significantly darker to the point I had to had max backlight at all times and even then the content is fuzzy and less paper like.

I went back to BW after that.

(it's amazing for comics and note taking though.)

I went with the Libra for the bigger screen and physical buttons. My kindle is certainly more pocketable, but that’s not a huge factor for me.

I do agree with the sibling comment on the eink display a I find I always need the backlight on to some degree which wasn’t the case for the kindle.

I bought a large format e-reader for the opposite reason - being able to read and study from large format textbooks while on long train journeys or in hotel rooms (or even camping). It handles stuff from arxiv fine too.

I really like my Boox Max, as it means that I can read textbooks at a good size without reflowing. It still holds charge for several weeks at a time after about 7 years

I wish I had it at university instead of 1000+ page hardback calculus textbooks.

I had a Kindle and quite liked it, but I also have an iPad and when the Kindle died I decided I didn’t need two devices in that form factor even though eink is great for the beach.

I would consider buying another eink device, but only if the price came down a lot. The market is still fairly small for eink, so there hasn’t really been much economy of scale. I just looked it up and apparently eink still costs 5-10x more than LCD to manufacture.

This Boox device would have to be closer to $50 (and not $200) to tempt me to add yet another gadget to my collection.

I’m considering one of these $69 readers https://www.xteink.com/

Looks cool, but if I have to copy Epubs to it, then that severely limits it's use for me with library books.

Maybe one day they'll have a version with Android on it.

calibre plus plugins solves for this

Actually seems like a really cool product, not sure if it would be that useful for any serious reading due to the small size but probably useful for displaying a calendar and other widgets.

I just bought one. I want the form factor, not for reading long form ebooks. Out the door with a case and screen covers it was about $120 USD. We shall see how it all goes.

Here's a video I recorded of me reading Hacker News on my Hisense A9 eink smartphone (it came out before the Palma, and hardware has been rock solid.)

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=onvSjhubvQ8

I recently jailbroke my Kindle 6th generation (which still works great!), installed KUAL, made a DeDRMed backup of my library, and installed a custom screensaver. It still works to buy titles off the Amazon store, too.

It's probably the single best electronic device I own. I once dropped it in a pool and it stopped working for a few weeks, but it came back on its own.

This device is very appealing to me, but I never pulled the trigger due to horror stories about screen cracking issues reported on reddit. (Sometimes the screen just breaks by itself despite sitting on a desk.) Repair is also expensive. This seems a risky purchase.

I read a lot, mostly ebooks, and have an extensive collection of DRM free ebooks. That said, e-ink devices are ridiculously overpriced, seemingly because e-ink tech is patent-encumbered. Fortunately I don't mind reading on LCD and OLED screens, have been doing that for 20 years, originally on PalmOS devices.

I'd love to get a Kobo to run Koreader but not until prices have come down to under $200 for a 8" device. I'm also consideeing the PocketBook Verse, the SD card slot means I could carry my entire 67GB collection with me..

FWIW I have a kobo Clara HD from circa 2018 with koreader and I see no reason to upgrade.

You can definitely get a used one for less than 200$

It has wifi, you can replace the SD card inside, and it has two backlights (cold and warm)

I ended up ordering a new PocketBook Verse from LaptopsDirect here in the UK, for £120, so about $160. I think it has the same e-ink generation as yours, and by all accounts B&W e-ink is crisper than the washed-out color e-ink displays.

I was referring more to the 8" to 10" e-readers, which are over $400, some over $700, for that price I'd rather get another iPad or Pixel Tablet. Hopefully e-ink tech is going to get cheaper when the patents expire, but that's 2032 or so, a long time away.

I use the bigme hibreak pro as my primary device. Its an eink device but also just a full phone. Almost bought the boox palma, but held back because I only really want to carry a single device.

The new Boox Palma 2 Pro is also a phone. And it runs Android 15! Has a stylus, but don't know how good it is (can be a super killer feature).

Just saw a review on YT. The stylus doesnt attach to the device, the writing experience seems ok but I wouldn't call it a killer feature.

Also it uses a color e-ink Kaleido which I personally find useless : the colors are still too washed out to be useful and the contrast is horrible with no backlight compared to B&W e-ink.

But it's still an interesting device.

It has a sim slot and can do data but no phone and no volte support.

Nice find, I'll add the name to my list.

I don't know about everyone else, but I find that I hate having to hold my e-reader. Also some years ago when I had 3 months of recovery time for a back operation I bought a tablet holder, which I have since attached to what is now my reading chair.

You can also now get some really nice magnetic y-shape arms that you rest on a table or surface (or wrap around something) that can hold a light e-reader magnetically without trouble.

I've been using this for a long time- it stays in my pocket/bag most days, and it's so inconspicuous (looks exactly like a phone) that you don't think twice about doing some serious reading in public or on the train

Why not just... read on your phone then?

Because the shiny phone screen is unpleasant for reading?

I mean, I can't reach into your brain and experience your perceptions but the literal billions of people who read for hours a day on "shiny" phone screens seems to show that as a rather rare view.

That's a pretty weak argument, though. I use a vertical mouse because it helps my RSI tremendously. I don't think there's anyone else in my office with one. I'm in a tiny minority there. And yet, I like my vertical mouse and I'd rather use it than a normal one, no matter how many others prefer the horizontal kind.

Luckly my parents got rid of socialism in the country to I could have a choice of products that fit me instead of being one-size-fits-all form shoved onto me.

I really don't understand why some of you really want that to come back.

Command economies are a component of some past socialist regimes. They are not a defining feature of socialism as a political and economic philosophy. I'm tired of socialist=bad and related categorical rhetorics. It's nuanced: where did worker unions, welfare programmes come from? And, to say that worker unions are a socialist thing is, in a way, lazy thinking too: there were specific initiatives, organizations and, above all, people that spearheaded these things we take for granted, but noone remembers them and some guy on a forum just lumps them into the "socialism" bag, which, again, is correct, but lazy and surely unuseful.

Maybe a more acceptable statement than saying LCDs are unpleasant: eInk screens are generally more pleasant for reading than LCDs.

They «read» for shorter amounts of time. Reading for hours on an OLED can be fatiguing, especially if you stare at a LCD at work for 8-10 hours everyday on top of your reading

There are matte screen covers, I have one and it's great.

Wow what a novel question that nobody in this thread has ever considered...

Absolutely love my boox palma! Since getting it I’ve read dozens of books, just because it’s so easy to carry. The complaints I’ve read before on Reddit don’t seem to apply to my device which is good.

been so tempted to try one but concerned about long term updates and viability

if it runs android 13, how long will it get updates for? how long until the apps you're using won't be updated?

i'd like my ebook reader to last years without issue

my oasis from 2020 still does all the things i need it to though i'd like to get a good reason to leave the kindle ecosystem but still want to have access to all the books i've purchased to read on eink

i kind of also wonder if other companies, i.e. kobo, will jump into this form factor given the popularity of boox

I really liked my palma but the display broke randomly (not the screen) while in a soft pocket within 3m of getting it. Support was no help. I just won't trust them again

I still don't understand why this needs to run Android. If you're looking for a much simpler and much cheaper device ($70 vs $200-$300) I would recommend the xteink x4.

The benefit for me with the boox series is access to the kindle app on play store. And obsidian.

The Xteink is almost two inches smaller than the Palma. I remember trying to read on early iphones that were 4.6-5 and hated the experience, the extra height matters.

More reasons/hooks to use the device that slow you down a little and make you more mindful

my $100 mobiscribe lets me read HN. I only read online on my eink devices. LCD is much less enjoyable

I'm still waiting for a rugged e-reader with a touchscreen that fits both A4 and letter sheets of paper without zooming in and out. 210x280mm

I’ve never used it but I have worked with people that love it and use it constantly. It is niche but AFAICT is love by people in that niche.

Boox Tab Mini C paired with Readwise Reader has been my go to for quite some time now and it hasn't slowed down in any noticeable way

If it is the size of my phone, I would avoid the future e-waste and just use my phone. In airplane mode, if distrations are a problem.

A eink screen is nicer to read on for long periods of reading.

Amazon killed Kindle for me by changing collections layout: managing a large collection is impossible.

Have you seen the OBook5? Its similar form factor but only $89

I love my Boox Go, I run the Storyteller app on it.

After lots of hand-wringing and research and trying Kindle & Kobo, I decided to read on my iPad and iPhone. They have accessibility features like low light mode to make it easy on the eyes, I can always read on the go with my phone and they can handle large full color books and PDFs too. The iPad has basically all notifications disabled and no distractions installed so it feels like a reader.

I have a Kindle, multiple iPads and an iPhone.

I only read on my iPad and iPhone because they are on-hand almost anywhere I am.

To me, the e-reading discussion is the same as the notetaking software discussion -- people obsess over the best form factor, but really most of the benefit comes from "just doing it" and keeping at it.

Most people gear up but they never end up doing it (reading continuous or taking notes).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com