Hacker News Reader

Comment by GaryBluto | Hacker News Reader

When did this notion that caring about things and wanting things to be professional is bad, or makes you a "man-child"? That would mean that practically everybody in human history has been a man-child. It feels like the whole world (even formerly professional areas) have decided to be casual and it's frustrating to those who think things matter.

View on HN

I want less professionalism, thanks. I think the idea that everything needs to be an emotionless product has been largely harmful to the internet as a place of community and expression.

Professional =/= emotionless or product. I'd argue that early Linux, with all of Linus' rants, was more professional than most companies today.

I suppose it all comes down to what your definition of "professional" is.

Adhering to a narrow definition of a "professional" look signifies immaturity, stemming from a desire for approval from a stereotypically "adult" third party. Personally, I wouldn't take seriously anyone who has a problem with Anubis but doesn't blink when presented with people drawn in the corporate Memphis style.

Whole countries of comparable size to the US happily put similar mascots all over their products, and pay other companies big money to use their characters. They're all over busses and billboards. The Korean ramen brand I buy has Kpop Demon Hunters on it now. (And Buldak usually has their little chicken dude.) Casio and Fender have expensive products with Hatsune Miku on them...which has been used in ad campaigns by petroleum and rail companies in Japan.

American corporate culture is dehumanizing and dystopian, not a standard for professionalism.

>Adhering to a narrow definition of a "professional" look signifies immaturity, stemming from a desire for approval from a stereotypically "adult" third party.

I'm not looking for anyone's approval. If I was, I wouldn't be publicly disagreeing with people on an internet forum, would I? Relax with your armchair psychology.

> Personally, I wouldn't take seriously anyone who has a problem with Anubis but doesn't blink when presented with people drawn in the corporate Memphis style.

I don't like either and find them both ugly.

> wanting things to be professional

Nothing says "professional" like starting a debate on HN about the weirdness of the mascot of a free software project, likely for political reasons.

> likely for political reasons.

You're engaging in bad faith here. Nobody has brought up politics at all. If an almost identical clone of myself (with the same opinions on everything but mascots) developed a software project with an anime mascot I'd still disapprove.

> That would mean that practically everybody in human history has been a man-child.

I would argue that this statement is blatantly false. Currently, most people really do not care about anubis anime cat girl icon which is actually fairly tame and boring picture.

In history, people used all kind of images for professional things, including stuff they found funny or cute.

Why is this worse than the octocat?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com