Hacker News Reader

Comment by darkhorn | Hacker News Reader

I think the most proper thing for the jet should be to destroy itself. In a war enviornment I would not like my enemy to gain intel about my military jets.

View on HN

Not my wheelhouse, but doesn't that involve packing the aircraft with explosives, and wouldn't that involve risk of blowing up if someone else shoots you? Or is there some better way to self-destruct?

Impacting the ground usually does it.

Jets are usually full of jet fuel that can blow up if someone else shoots you, or they run into the ground.

Assuming there is an autopilot present, nose diving at max afterburner straight down is probably going to yield a similar result

One could calculate the amount of energy in a given amount of explosive and smashing into the ground at high velocity. I'm too lazy to do so, but I can tell you they're on the same scale.

A heavy object moving fast has a shocking amount of energy. When such an object impacts the ground, all that energy has to go somewhere.

There are probably a number of clever and failsafe ways to divert jet fuel somewhere that would destroy the plane on command.

You could self-destruct just the software / computers by encrypting everything with a few keys that are easy to destroy.

This is a standard technique for quick and secure data wipes, particularly on e.g. modern SSD drives where a traditional wipe might be incomplete due to wear leveling algorithms.

You could erase computer memory, but blowing up the plane won't stop them from gaining intel about the materials, mechanism, and whatnot that make up the plane. An explosion won't vaporize the airplane, just break it into smallish pieces. Those can be collected and analyzed to reconstruct most any detail about the construction of the airplane. They even do this with missiles and bombs. Even shell fragments. When artillery shells packed full of high explosives go off, their intricate fuse mechanisms are left remarkably intact.

I think its high-speed collision with the ground or ocean generally takes care of destroying it. Especially with no pilot attempting to keep it level and slow it down and minimize damage.

Would you go near a plane that's an electronic signal away from blowing itself up?

Even if mechanical, warplanes get combat damage, and having a system like that could make a difference between survivable and sure death.

Maybe bring some strong jamming equipment to prevent the electronic signal from being received?

The signal can originate on the plane itself due to a software glitch, stray currents in the grounding skin or whatever. If anything, jammers tend to interfere with the carrier's electronics itself.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com