Hacker News Reader

Comment by jen20 | Hacker News Reader

This is the reason I refused to buy Nanit cameras, instead opting for unconnected models. E2E encryption is table stakes.

View on HN

By the way you dont need a video (or hell even audio) baby monitor. Source: 2 kids.

Same here. I wonder if the market is for first-time parents and people who work 8+ hour days.

I used to work with my laptop, sitting near my baby. Also, I used a timer to follow 45m sleep patterns, so technically there’s no need to react to anything within first 45m, but most times first 1h30m (45+45m).

Of course you don't _need_ it, but it's a useful convenience. Due to the layout of our house it was quite hard to hear my toddler if he was crying in the middle of the night - we often wouldn't wake up to it. So the monitor was very helpful.

Why on earth do you need an app and a camera? The same basic VTech audio monitors that are basically the same for many decades now work great, don't cost a fortune and there's no question of "where is this data going?" It's all just a big cash grab for people who need chincy tech toys for a non-problem that's better solved with way more simple kit.

You misunderstand; we're on the same wavelength. I'm not talking about an app, I'm talking about a basic audio baby monitor.

> Why on earth do you need an app and a camera?

The comment you’re replying to literally started by saying you don’t need it.

Of course you don’t need it. But it’s very useful, especially living in a house with a layout that doesn’t lend itself to hearing a pin drop in the next room.

The v-tech ones are fine though. No need for anything with an Internet connection (though some of them even do now).

Source: also 2 kids.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com