Hacker News Reader

Don't we have tens of thousands of hours (hundreds of thousands?) of closed captioned tv shows and movies? How many hours of news broadcasts with transcripts do we have? Maybe I just don't understand what is needed, but it seems like we have a lot of data to work with.

View on HN

Correct me if I’m wrong but you need more than just closed captions. You need precise timing too. I’d think you’d need the text to line up exactly with the audio so when the voice makes an “A” sound the text it aligns with is “A” as well.

So while having the closed captions saves some of the work, there is probably much more needed to get everything lined up.

But I’m absolutely not an expert at all. In fact this is the first I’ve ever even though about it!

Author here. Speech-to-text is more or less solved, it's easy to automatically get captions including precise timestamps. For training Moshi, Kyutai's audio LLM, my colleagues used whisper-timestamped to transcribe 7 million hours of audio.

See Section 4.2 in the Moshi paper: https://arxiv.org/pdf/2410.00037

Sweet!

Sure but that needs to be licensed

Reply on news.ycombinator.com