Hacker News Reader

Here’s another: https://suno.com/s/v3LuDD9SjVPohVB7

I listened to both and they both sounded soul-less.

Seemed adequately soulful to me. Not my favorite, but better than I could do. As another bit of anecdata.

Thx

Depends on what you mean by souless. According to the textbook definition, as someone who’s been into music production for more than 20 years in one capacity or another, and that has listened to innumerable songs across every genre imaginable, agree to disgree.

Not to your liking sure, maybe you think it even sucks. But souless nah

I did not feel anything when listening to the song. The purpose of music is to move oneself, particularly emotionally.

As an example to represent the point - this is known to put many on the verge of tears/in a stream of tears: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WxNbZLh0PaA&list=RDWxNbZLh0P...

The beauty of music is that it’s based on preference.

Some songs that move my friends have absolutely no effect on me, and vice versa. That doesn’t mean the song is soulless - it is just that the preferences don’t align.

Lol, you are not someone worth debating with. Stick to your biases and continue producing music that no one else cares about. Cool.

Just dont share it with the rest of us who actually have taste.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com