Hacker News Reader

So if I illegally speed does that make me a criminal. Would you classify me by that one action, or the many other ones I do each day? By your definition a great number of the people that live on this earth would be classified as criminals.

View on HN

So if I illegally speed does that make me a criminal.

Yes. Speeding endangers other people so that you can get somewhere slightly faster.

No. Moving violations are not necessarily crimes. In Massachusetts, I think that reckless driving is a crime (usually interpreted as 20MPH), but I know that plain ol' speeding is not. If you contest, you see a magistrate; if you appeal the magistrate's decision, you do get a trial with a judge, but the ticket itself is considered evidence of your speeding.

The point is, when you speed, you take something from someone else for your own benefit and that's the essence of criminality.

You took my attention away to read your pathetic comment, I pronounce you a criminal.

And I'm a psychopath because I don't care!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com