Comment by pedalpete | Hacker News Reader

Comment by pedalpete | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

This time is always different, until it isn't.

However, it is different from the internet bubble partially for the reason you describe.

There have been a few IPOs, but they perhaps happened earlier in the cycle, or companies are pivoting into AI. I'm thinking companies like Palantir, which was always AI, or Salesforce which is making a big AI pivot.

Most of the funding is not coming from public sectors. There is so much private capital available that it isn't necessary. I believe the bubble is in VC, which some would think is find because it protects public markets from the crash, but I'm not sure that is correct.

When the VC money stops flowing into AI, I think it will send a shockwave through the public markets. The huge valuations of companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, etc will be repriced, which will probably force a re-pricing of public darlings like Palantir, Microsoft, NVIDIA.

If VC funds aren't buying NVIDIA chips and building data centers, everyone will feel the need to re-price.

It's emotional, not logical.

It may be true that OAI et al are raising money in private markets, but does that matter? Ultimately they are still just raising money. Ultimately returns need to show up. You cannot escape that. If you cannot do that nobody will eventually supply the funds to keep operating.

The big advantage of staying private is controlling the narrative.

Because the comment was specifically pointing out that this doesn't seem like a bubble because there aren't many IPOs or public pure play AI companies.

Historically, the worst busts following the bursting of an asset price bubble, in terms of real economic impact, have been from debt fueled bubbles (Great Depression, Global Financial Crisis). You can read Hyman Minsky and Irving Fisher for a detailed analysis of why, but it mainly comes down to the fact that the financial obligations remain once prices and expectations have reset.

Then you have the busts that follow public equity fueled bubbles (Dotcom crash). Nowhere near as bad as the former, but still a moderate impact on the economy due to the widely dispersed nature of the equity holdings and the resulting wealth effect.

What we have now is more of a narrowly held private equity bubble (acknowledging that there's still an impact through the SP500 given widespread index investing). If OpenAI, Anthropic, Perplexity, and a bunch of AI startups go bust, who loses money and what impact does it have on the rest of the economy?

How was Palantir always AI?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com