Hacker News Reader

Comment by wkat4242 | Hacker News Reader

Yeah I use different methods for that. I considered using zfs send/receive for backups, however there's one big issue with that: every time you need one or two files from the backup you need to restore the whole filesystem. There's no official way to retrieve a single file from a zfs send stream.

For backup purposes I also greatly prefer file by file encryption because one corruption will only break one file and not the whole backup.

What I do now is encrypt with encfs and store on a S3 glacier-style service.

View on HN

I can only think of one situation where it's hard to retrieve a remote backup of an individual file; where ZFS native encryption is in use and the remote backup system is not trusted to load the key for the dataset.

For myself, I don't trust remote systems to always have keys loaded, but in an emergency I would feel relatively safe temporarily loading the key, mounting the snapshot read-only, and scp-ing the files out, then unmounting and unloading the key (and rebooting for good measure).

There's also a viable slow option; export the raw storage of the backup ZFS pool over the (inter)network to a trusted machine and import the pool read-only locally, load the key, mount the filesystem, and make a copy. Much slower but is practical. I've used s3backer fairly successfully as a backup method for a pool with native encryption; it takes a minute or so to import the pool and can write backup snapshots at a few MB/s, so there shouldn't be any fundamental reason iscsi or similar wouldn't work.

I've never had to restore a single file that's older than my local snapshots; The restores where I've needed an old subset have been a substantial enough subset that 4-5xing the data size on restore was not really an issue.

I kinda agree with your point on file-by-file encryption, but ZFS's general integrity features are such that I'm not really worried - Except about this article's specific failure mode, which is pretty easy to deal with/avoid when you know about it, but is a substantial deficiency.

You don't actually have to restore the entire snapshot if you just want a single file! ZFS mounts snapshots read-only in an extra hidden .zfs/snapshot directory that doesn't even show up in ls -a unless you set snapdir=visible on the dataset but you can copy files out of there.

For example, cp /path/to/dataset/mountpoint/.zfs/snapshot/<snapshot_name>/path/to/file ~/path/to/file

Reply on news.ycombinator.com