From the HN guidelines:
"Resist complaining about being downmodded. It never does any good, and it makes boring reading."
Would you prefer to be spat on instead?
I'm beginning to suspect my writing style is prone to misunderstanding, though. C'est la vie.
You've been bravely standing behind your words, even in the face of the "public shaming" of so many downmods. That's respectable.
Besides, should a downvote be used to express mere disagreement, or reserved for posts that one thinks are really inappropriate or maybe jarringly stupid?
In any case, I agree that insulting someone or calling them names should not be a crime, and that spitting on someone shouldn't be considered an "assault" (with the provisions you mentioned).
Under some interpretations of US law, a 22 year old taking nude photo's of them self could be prosecuted for creating child porn if they look 16.
I think if you asked a thousand people off the street:
Is that accurate? Is that moral? Is that a travesty of justice? Is that reasonable?
You would get yes, no, and sort of to all of those questions and it's not really a "major" hot topic.
I do wish those guidelines had something about why to mod up or down, though. Modding something down or up simply because you happen to agree, regardless of the quality or validity of the argument presented, will also lead to boring reading - the majority view, endlessly repeated, since it's the only "safe" thing to post.
In defense of the site though, your initial downmodded comment was rather condescending and showed a lack of knowledge of the area. Responding to someones idea with "Huh? You really think that?" isn't very respectful and it shows a certain amount of arrogance. Arrogance is frowned upon pretty heavily here. It doesn't add anything to the discussion when you are correct and is just plain obnoxious when you are wrong. Be humble about what you know, ask questions about what you don't, and provide logical arguments for what you think. That's a big part of what sets this site apart from a lot of the other sites like it.
I assume you're a moderator - although they're much appreciated by myself, these well-written tips will just get lost in the noise here. You might consider adding them to the FAQ yourself : )
For example, saying: "I can't believe you people are downmodding me." will most likely just cause people to pile on and punish you.
But saying: "To those downmodding me, if you think I meant this, I really meant that." or "Just to clarify, I meant it this way." will often defuse a misunderstanding and cause people to at least put you back up to 1.
Really the key is to be civil. It's rare that someone gets dogpiled just for dissenting. However, if you dissent in a rude manner, people are tempted to see how negative one comment can get.
To the trusting souls who upvoted this show of sincerity: what he did next was write a program to spam the site with 545 identical comments.