Hacker News Reader

Comment by syndacks | Hacker News Reader

How did you come to that conclusion that this is a function of betting? As a baseball fan, this feels like a long overdue feature (at least in the world of video review challenge). I think it's simply going to make the game better. MLB is losing to the NFL/NBA, and they need to put out a better product.

View on HN

They’ve had the technology for over 20 years. The only thing that’s changed in the last 5 is betting.

I couldn't count the number of things that have changed in the last five years. However, related to Baseball here's a small list to start. https://www.baseball-almanac.com/rulechng.shtml

There's also Angel Hernández retiring.

I don't know how any baseball fan can be against this. I would bet that man has made at least one season-ending mistake on every team out there throughout his career, and he's completely unapologetic and arrogant about it. Everyone was relieved when he retired, but there's been plenty of others happy to play the king villain now.

But pitchers should still have to bat. Pinch hitters offend me.

For the National League. Abolish the DH in that National League.

> They’ve had the technology for over 20 years. The only thing that’s changed in the last 5 is betting.

What has not changed since before both of those timelines is baseball umpires have a union[0].

Maybe, just maybe, their union fought the introduction of this to the bitter end.

0 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Major_League_Baseball_Umpires_...

Manfred (Commissioner) started 10 years ago.

He oversaw the last collective bargaining agreement in 2021/22. It’s expiring this year. That’s one of the reasons why the rule change is going through now.

I won’t deny that sports betting could be a factor, but Manfred wants faster more engaging baseball. That’s been his stated goal for a long time as he worked through rule changes.

That makes absolutely no sense. If it’s a chip in the collective bargaining agreement, why would he give it away for free prior to negotiations beginning?

Why would the owners? “Good will” has never worked in MLB negotiations and I don’t see that changing.

You may be correct, but the rate of change in baseball is glacially slow compared to the other sports. One of baseball's intrinsic values is it's legacy, tradition, and history. Some may scoff at that, and I think there are good arguments against legacy/tradition as a reason to withhold change, but there are a lot of people out there that believe this. The MLB Commissioner's have largely been tasked with protecting that tradition and history.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com