Hacker News Reader

Comment by bakugo | Hacker News Reader

Brand new account, 7 different comments on this post, all aggressively trying to discredit it.

A bit suspicious, don't you think?

Nope. How else are they supposed to make comments if they didn't have an account here yet? I had to create this account just to answer you—is that suspicious too?

It’s a fair observation.

Their comments are extremely high confidence (failing to recognize that accidents and supply chain attacks do sometimes happen) and because they are new and posting frequently in the same thread, their account shows the signs of a bot/disinfo campaign (which does happen on HN).

It's a completely useless observation. Doesn't add anything productive to the topic.

It's not useless, a new account commenting what amounts to "There's nothing wrong, stop looking", multiple times, is the opposite of assuring.

no one said stop looking; simply that OP was wildly misinformed and he proved nothing of any value

> I had to create this account just to answer you—is that suspicious too?

No, but if you were to make 6 more comments under the same post all saying the same thing in an overly confident and aggressive tone, it would be.

And yet, I probably would have done that if he hadn't done it first. Your incitement to suspicion is highly biased and also an ad hominem diversion.

You can back up a debunking with receipts or reputation. Ideally, both.

You and anotherlogin448 have neither, but also show incredible aggression towards anyone pointing that out.

Your confidence might actually be warranted, but there's no reason for any one of us to take you on your word, and neither of you have given anything else.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com