Hacker News Reader

Comment by guizmo | Hacker News Reader

I see it as Nazi Germany and the de-nazification process. Reconstruction and economic prosperity combined with re-education program lead by the allies occupying the different zones with a clear time-limited mandate. US occupation of Japan after WW2 might also provide some ideas on how it could work.

I don't think letting the Nazi regime or the Japan regime survive the war would have been a great idea. I think the same about Hamas.

I wonder what would have been the views in the West at the time if TikTok existed and people saw the war as vividly. I can only imagine how the Nazi propaganda would have worked out on the US for example.

View on HN

> de-nazification

It was very superficial, though. The German government was still full of nazis until the entire generation who held power in the nazis regime died out. They became extremely lenient and protective towards war criminals as soon as the allies stopped caring.

Of course that’s unlikely to work in Gaza since Hamas (and similar organizations) are inherently unwilling to compromise about anything unlike the [former] nazis in Germany.

Have you considered that the rest of world is increasingly looking at the Likud Party the same way you view Nazi Germany? Israel is desperately in need of a forceful re-education program. Unfortunately, being a nuclear-armed state makes regime change extremely difficult to achieve on any reasonable timeframe.

I'm not Israeli. I'm part of the rest of the world and many people where I live and many other countries have the same view as I do about the right of Israel to military action to destroy Hamas.

I think there is a much widespread support for Israel than you think. And that the accusation of genocide are meant to silence this support as much as possible.

The US (and the UK) did massive damages to my country and particularly my region, while fighting against the Nazis, leveling cities and killing tens of thousands of French citizens. My grand parents had to flee on foot as far as possible from the combat zones on the request of the allies. There even was reports of hundreds of rape and even murders from US troops at the Liberation. And it was much much worse in Germany...

No one in their right mind would talk about the US pursuing a genocide against the Germans or the Normans.

We don't judge the US based on this, but based on the results they achieved and what they did after the war. I think most Germans also believe this.

I will also judge Israel based on what they do after Hamas is defeated. I hope they do the right thing, as the US did. And I believe they will and that it is in their best interest to do so.

It's good you recognize the need of a re-education program and regime change. Once one side gets re-education and the right leadership, the conflict can be solved peacefully and both sides can coexist productively. You seem to have concluded the wrong party needs those things.

There is a fringe minority in Israel (who seem to be very influential politically due to various reasons) who are only marginally better than Hamas, though.

> the Likud Party the same way you view Nazi Germany

Well.. that’s a highly hyperbolized statement. It’s still a very fringe/minority view.

Even if Israel didn’t have nuclear weapons no Western power would be willing to overhaul its regime or let alone invade it (and obviously there wouldn’t be sufficient public support for it either even in France or Britain e.g. even recognizing Palestine is not particularly popular https://www.jns.org/nearly-75-of-french-oppose-macron-push-t...).

Reply on news.ycombinator.com