Hacker News Reader

Comment by esalman | Hacker News Reader

All it'll do is replace competent workers who don't have $100k to spare, with incompetent workers who have the money.

I certainly don't think the industry's hiring processes are perfect, but $100k on top of a normal wage for an incompetent worker is a lot of money to throw down the drain and not either run out of money or have someone competent notice and stop the situation before too long.

> $100k ... is a lot of money

It's still less than a domestic recruiting fee for many types of roles the H1B was purportedly about, roles where it's hard enough to find someone you need a headhunter's help and the pool is still not exactly what you're looking for.

Unfortunately, to stop the situation you either need to let competent foreign workers in, or somehow make 2 years of masters education, or 7 years of PhD education more attractive to average Americans than flipping burgers and earning $22 an hour, on top of taking hundreds of thousands of dollars loan to get bachelor's degrees.

False dichotomy. Why would only incompetent workers have the 100k to spare?

There's a reason why corrupt politicians and extortionists all over the world choose to retire in the US.

The fees are paid by employers and not workers.

Without salary enforcement, it does come out of workers eventually.

Like Americans paying Tariff fees out of their wallets due to price hikes.

This is still another loophole and the companies which exploit the program and workers (small consulting firms, not big tech per se) are still going to exploit this.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com