Hacker News Reader

It's also full of non-icann extensions. So a naive implementation will identify "github.io" as a TLD. There are lots of nuances to working with this list. Our team has a pretty robust internal (Python) library now that we hope to open source soon.

View on HN

The whole point of PSL is to identify "github.io" as a TLD. Anyone can create a subdomain of it. Just like anyone can create a new subdomain of "com" (a real TLD).

The difference is you don't register a domain under github.io, you merely loan it. Some countries, like Poland, have a bunch that are real domain suffixes

https://www.dns.pl/en/list_of_functional_domain_names

Loaning or renting (registering) amount to the same thing for the purposes of the the public suffix list: because the *public* can create entries under github.io, you cannot assume that alice.github.io and eve.github.io are controlled by the same entity, so you should not share alice.github.io's data (e.g. cookies) with eve.github.io.

There is no formal ICANN TLD list. The PSL is your best shot. So it is actually wrong to assume that your situation is the sole purpose.

For instance, https://data.iana.org/TLD/tlds-alpha-by-domain.txt

Where is .co.uk ? That is - for all intents and purposes - considered a TLD.

So PSL is currently doing double-duty and the distinction is very important.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com