Hacker News Reader

Comment by throw8924389 | Hacker News Reader

And yesterday the Munich Philharmonic was uninvited from an event in Brussel, because their conductor is from Israel.

It's antisemitism, plain and simple.

For instance, nobody would ban a US pop star from an international event just because many disagree with the current policies of the US government.

Compare to the countless global conflicts we have seen in the last decades, including the reactions and overreactions and including wars and military force and ask yourself, why Israel is singled out and moreover why individual jews that are living abroad are singled out.

View on HN

The same munich philharmonic that fired their last conductor because of his unwillingness to denounce putin? Very interesting development!

> because their conductor is from Israel

I believe the issue is not that he is "from israel" but that he is currently the music director of the israeli philharmonic orchestra.

Anti-sionisme*

We ban Russian athletes because Russia is waging a war on Ukraine and the Russian head of state is a wanted war criminal.

Israel should be double banned then because they are doing a proven genocide on the Palestinian population and their head of state is also a wanted war criminal.

https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cde3eyzdr63o

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Criminal_Court_a...

It's like inviting Hitler supporters to a garden party.

> For instance, nobody would ban a US pop star from an international event just because many disagree with the current policies of the US government.

If and while the US conduct a new genocide on a population (their previous one to the native American population is too far in history to judge the current US populace), I hope we don't invite their pop stars to sing for us.

There's nothing proven about the genocide libel. That BBC article is about an association (IAGS) where anyone with $30 can join, whether they are a scholar or not. Twitter/X had a fun time with that over the last week, signing up as genocide scholars under ridiculous names. Furthermore IAGS has around 500 members, and only 129 of them voted with 86% of those supporting the resolution.

Here's 514 scholars calling for IAGS to retract: https://www.scholarsfortruthaboutgenocide.com/

“Genocide is the gravest offense known to humankind; to dilute its legal standards for ideological ends is a form of moral violence. It dishonors the memory of past victims, misleads the public about present atrocities, and obstructs efforts to avert future ones,” the Friday statement said.

Stop bombing childrens that did nothing while promoting real estate on the rubles and we'll stop the libel.

I am not very interested in debating with a genocide apologist the finer points whether bombing hospitals, starving children and ethnically cleansing the Palestinian population has to be approved as genocide by 98% or 99% of experts.

There are people up to this very day who deny the Holocaust happened as well and call it a libel. Hitler was stopped regardless, the same will happen to the genocider Netanyahu. Its "Never again", not "Again, but this time we are doing it to others".

Israel is doing a genocide.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com