Hacker News Reader

Some tools talk to docker not using the docker CLI but directly through its REST API. Podman also exposes a similar REST API[1]. Is Podman with its API server switched on substantially different from the docker daemon?

[1]. https://docs.podman.io/en/latest/markdown/podman-system-serv...

View on HN

Docker daemon runs as root, and runs continuously.

If you're running rootless Podman containers then the Podman API is only running with user privileges. And, because Podman uses socket activation, it only runs when something is actively talking to it.

Sometimes it's possible to not use the Podman API at all. Convert the compose file to quadlet files with the command-line tool podlet and start the container with "systemctl --user start myapp.service". Due to the fork/exec architecture of podman, the container can then be started without using the Podman API.

Yes, either quadlet or handwritten podman CLI in .service files is the way to go. I don't like using generate-systemd because it hides the actual configuration of the container, I see no point in being stateful...

Yes because the API server is stateless, unlike the docker daemon. If you kill it you can still operate on containers, images, etc. by other means, whereas if you kill the docker daemon the CLI stops working too.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com