I think the number of chickens killed last year could be higher than the number of humans killed since 0 A.D. by an animal.
That's easily true. 75 billion chickens are slaughtered every year, and the estimate for total historical human population is a little over 100 billion, most of whom died for reasons other than animal attack.
"Well you might have won 99.99999999% times but I one once so let's call it a draw."