Hacker News Reader

Comment by alex_young | Hacker News Reader

In case anyone else is wondering - Robin is the ex-wife of another prominent linguist, George Lakoff.

Somehow GPT-5 got this badly wrong when I first asked:

  Yes — George Lakoff and Robin Lakoff are related. They are siblings.

Er, no. They were married once and divorced 50 years ago according to their Wikipedia pages.

View on HN

What a fascinating semantic mistake. Is it possible being long-divorced is more similar to being siblings than we realize?

I would sincerely hope not.

This question may well be the rosetta stone for the cultural divide over AI.

I don't think it means much except you need to enable "web" or searching at least for most models to deal well with facts, and that's probably for the better.

Even a basic search tool + GPT-OSS-20b handles it correctly it seems to me (https://gist.github.com/victorb/de69a8c2169e6a7cc1989592419b...), if I guessed what prompt you used correctly, "Were George Lakoff and Robin Lakoff related?".

Reply on news.ycombinator.com