Hacker News Reader

Comment by anal_reactor | Hacker News Reader

I disagree. I see absolutely no problem with anthropomorphizing LLMs, and I do that myself all the time. I strongly believe that we shouldn't focus on how a word is defined in dictionary, but rather what's the intuitive meaning behind it. If talking to an LLM feels like talking to a person, then I don't see a problem with seeing it as a person-like entity.

View on HN

> we shouldn't focus on how a word is defined in dictionary [sic], but rather ... the ... meaning behind it.

This is a spectacularly, objectively invalid take.

Uh-uh. Funnily, the dictionary always represents the language of certain upper class which are the minority, and they often refuse to acknowledge words used by lower classes because fuck you that's why. Not to mention that dictionary is always, by definition, outdated.

I think it is one dictionary authors would agree with? Dictionaries do not dictate the meanings of words; they document them.

Now, within some contexts it is best to stick to standard precise definitions for some words. Still, the meaning of a word within a community is determined by how it is used and understood within that community, not by what is in a dictionary.

Not always. Where I come from there's very strong push to speak the standard language, and regional variations are simply considered wrong. This leads to situations where words commonly used across the whole country don't make it to the dictionary because of petty office politics of those who make dictionaries. Changing the dictionary to allow things previously considered "wrong" would damage the reputation of scholars, who pride themselves in being exemplary.

> I strongly believe that we shouldn't focus on how a word is defined in dictionary, but rather what's the intuitive meaning behind it.

Controversies about the word niggardly ~ https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Controversies_about_the_word...

Humans deserve compassion because they suffer. That's what it means to treat someone like a person irrespective of what you believe.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com