Hacker News Reader

Comment by al_borland | Hacker News Reader

A camel is a horse designed by a committee.

It seems there is no shortage of markup languages. The benefits of markdown are simply its ubiquity. It has been shown time and time again that a technically better solution doesn’t win out based on technical merits alone. Every time I think about using something other than markdown, I need to stop myself, as the universal support is a bigger and more important “feature” than anything other markup languages may have. This popularity is in spite of the original markdown author not using it for all this stuff others use it for, and speaking out against its use for anything beyond basic web page generation.

View on HN

True. Wide-adoption makes markdown hard to beat.

However, I _would_ like to see a better alternative. My #1 feature request would be simple styling (beyond bold, italic, etc.) Specifically, some way to compactly color and highlight text. Something like [C#4c4|aaa]Text[/C] maybe where format is #{text-color-rgb}|{background-color-rgb} where background is optional. Likewise, something similar for font like [F:10pt,monospace]Test[/F]. Extra credit for named styles: [$danger=C#484|#cc8] and then [S:$danger]I'm dangerous[/S].

The problems with this ends up being the result becomes less human readable. At some point, why not just write HTML? You already have open and close brackets in your example. This is HTML with extra steps.

If the issue is the extra effort in typing some extra characters, emmet solved this a decade ago.

Thanks for the idea, it sounds interesting, I'll try to simplify the syntax for better understanding.

1. Inline styling with @

@color#4c4,bg#aaa Text @

color#hex for text color

bg#hex for background color

Multiple props separated by commas

Ends with another @ (so you can nest easier without clashing with brackets)

Example:

@color#fff,bg#f00 Danger!@

2. Fonts with @font

@font10pt,mono Code sample@

10pt = font size

mono = monospace (could also be serif, sans)

3. Named styles

@style$danger=color#484,bg#cc8@ @danger I'm dangerous@

First line defines the style name

Second line uses it with just @name …@

jones1618 What do you think?

Sounds good! My only observation is that, wherever possible, make it easier to see/scan-for text content.

So my text gets lost a bit in: @a-bunch-of-markup My Text is here@

Maybe add a visual delimiter, so: @a-bunch-of-markup:My Text is here:@

To my eye, this makes my content text stand out more clearly.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com