Hacker News Reader

wow I just listened to Eleven Music do flamenco singing. That is incredible.

Edit. I just tried it though and less impressed now. We are really going to need major music software to get on board before we have actual creative audio tools. These all seem made for non-musicians to make a very cookie cutter song from a specific genre.

View on HN

I also tried it for a full 100K credits (Wasted in 2 hours btw which is silly!).

Compared to both Udio and Suno, it's very very bad.. both at compositions, matching lyrics to music, keeping tempo and as soon as there's any distorted instruments like guitars or live, quality goes to radio-level.

>These all seem made for non-musicians to make a very cookie cutter song from a specific genre.

This is my main problem with AI music at the moment, I'd love it if I had proper creative control as a musician that'd be amazing but a lot of the time it's just straight up slop generation.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com