Many in the racing community share his opinions. All these things seem to accomplish is making you hot.
1) racing, and normal motorcycle use -- like the kind of accidents you run into commonly differ hugely
2) you being able to afford a end of the line product or being very budged constrained
and this are two important aspects completely ignored in this discussion
Every basic motorcycle safety class will urge you to get good boots. I just wished I had heeded that advise in time instead of buying them after my first crash ;-/