Hacker News Reader

Comment by Empro | Hacker News Reader

Wow. Samsung really needs to clean up its act.

To be fair to Samsung, I do not think this is a Samsung specific issue. It raises larger concerns about well known companies also like TNW, TheVerge, Engagdget etc. FWIW these websites directly affect consumer choices.

Wait a sec, a blogger goes to great pains to state that he won't shill for a company that's paying for his trip to a trade show. He verifies that this is okay with the company several times, and states categorically that he will cover other products and be impartial about Samsung's, repeatedly.

How does this "raise larger concerns" about these blogs? It seems like the blogger here has gone out of his way to ensure that his impartiality isn't challenged.

This sort of behavior - from Samsung or otherwise - is despicable. They need to be held to full account for this sort of fraud.

A lot of people have grossly misunderstood my statement. Please take a moment to think that in this specific instance the blogger refused to dance to Samsung's tunes and hence, got reported. If the blogger would have sgreed all this may have been swept under the carpet. Therefore, it raises "larger concerns" about bloggers who give product reviews.

I am in no sane mind defending Samsung or any of it's actions. I just want to take this incident to pause & introspect over the ongoings in the technology review industry.

http://www.theverge.com/ethics-statement

Compare with the sort-of ethics statement The Register used to produce.

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2001/01/22/register_tariff/

"Integrity — we've heard of it."

"With our Diamond Plus account you can have any Reg staffer's vital organs dispatched to you overnight."

I think we can safely say that that document is somewhat tongue in cheek.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com