Ask HN: What NAS (Synology) do you use in your home lab as a developer? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: What NAS (Synology) do you use in your home lab as a developer?

11 pointslavren197410 comments

I previously used Synology since 2016 but I'll never buy them again, due to a combination of how poor their hardware options are and how unfriendly their recent policy changes have been.

My next NAS will probably be an NVMe-only computer, lots of options emerging these days with 4 - 6 slots as China has become infatuated with designing small NAS.

I just built a new NAS using a raspberry pi5 and radxa SSD expansion hat, using openmediavault on the software side. Fairly painless setup, the kit is barebones but I 3d printed a custom case.

It is surprisingly good! 16gb of RAM so you can host all sorts of goodies, and you arent locked into vendor software. Its also extremely cheap to setup, the SSDs end up being the largest expense.

It does all this while using about a quarter of the power my old Thecus NAS did.

I got a cheap PC from

https://ithacareuse.org/

and run Linux on it. My take is that purpose-based NAS are a matter of "pay a lot more, get a lot less, give up all your control"

I want to launch it as media for TV as well

It has Ubuntu Linux, I installed a Plex server on it and have a Plex pass subscription for it. I also have one of these

https://www.silicondust.com/hdhomerun/

I have Plex clients for Windows, Mac, Linux, XBOX ONE, PS4 and iOS. I can watch TV and movies on my server or Live TV through the HDHomeRun, or have Plex work as a DVR. I listen to music on my phone with the Plexamp client when I am at work or travelling on foot or in my car. My only complaint is that some files don't play by default on the PS4 and I have to manually tell it to re-encode.

I tried Jellyfin and never got it to really work right. Plex is a consumer electronics-type experience and the Plex Pass is totally worth it.

You can do that with home-built ones. The only thing Synology (or any commercial NAS) actually gets you that you can't get elsewhere is convenience of setup.

I don't use a Synology NAS at all. I use a home-built one.

DS2419+ with a DX1215II expansion unit.

For years I used (and still do) UnRaid but cases with all hotswap bays were difficult to find that fit my needs. At the end of the day I want my NAS to be stupid simple to maintain and Synology (currently) fits that bill.

I am concerned with all the "Synology-branded drive" BS they are pushing and that might influence my next NAS purchase.

I use UnRaid as my "App" server still but Synology is the data layer (just NFS mounts to the UnRaid server).

Synology is expensive (comparatively) but it's been way easier to maintain/manage than my UnRaid servers (I have 3 pro licenses, or whatever the highest tier is/was before they moved to subscriptions). I wanted something that "just worked" and so far Synology has fit that bill.

I have a Synology NAS (DS720+), but it’s just a media and file server.

Does it have to be Synology? I recently replaced my 17 year old Drobo with a Ugreen NASync DXP4800 Plus, installed TrueNAS on it and couldn't be happier. Beautiful box with specs that Synology can't touch. Manufacturer is fairly new to the NAS game, but hey, I took a chance on Drobo back in the day and that worked out great.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com