Hacker News Reader

Comment by saalweachter | Hacker News Reader

I assume there are indeed some buyers who will indeed snap up the assets, but I do wonder "and then what?"

They trust that their bigger political clout will let them continue to employee undocumented migrant workers at wages no one else will work for?

They wait for the political climate to change, and then they'll go back to business as usual?

They wait for produce prices to skyrocket/the job market to crater, and then pay minimum wage for the jobs?

Something something, AI/robots?

View on HN

The cynic in me thinks that this is a way for bigger farms to gobble up smaller farms by calling in ice but knowing that they will be able to keep ice from raiding them unless a bigger farm pays to have them raided.

> They trust that their bigger political clout will let them continue to employee undocumented migrant workers at wages no one else will work for?

Yes, this is exactly what will happen.

I don’t think this is clear. They might just mechanise why have jobs when a machine can do the job just as well?

This assumes that a machine can do the job, but the present owners don't understand it. The article doesn't say "this will force farmers to mechanise more", see?

If a machine could have done the job it would be doing it right now.

Not if using illegal workers is cheaper.

Illegal migration makes it infeasible to invest in technology to automate the work, because any business that wants to invest in automation will be undercut by a less ethical competitor employing illegal, artificially cheap workers. This also makes it hard to attract investment for companies building technology to automate this work, because investors assume that the government will continue to not enforce the law, leading to reduced demand for labor-replacing technology. We won't get significant innovation and investment in this field until the government sends a clear message that they will be consistently enforcing the law going forward.

Wait it out. Cropland is a solid asset. Lots of soybean farmland for sale in my neck of the woods.

> "[...] but I do wonder 'and then what?'"

America's prison industry, one of the Trump administration's biggest profiteers, might have some relevant answers for you. ;)

At what quality? Most frameworks are paid by amount harvested so they bust their asses to pick all that fruit. What’s the motivation for prisoners to do more than the bare minimum? Related question, what will the other inmates do to the inmate who works much harder than everyone else?

Prison laborers generally get paid (very poorly).

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Penal_labor_in_the_United_Stat...

I'm sure a nation with such a... shall we say... "colorful" and rich history in prison and slave labor can muster some experts on the matter to answer your questions. Satisfaction guaranteed, or your money back. Et cetera.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com