Hacker News Reader

> when the purchasing power of the working class has been falling steadily for the last 45 years

Yeah? How much did an always-on pocket sized computer connected to the internet cost in 1980?

Manufacturing a pocket sized computer has become equivalently easier as it is cheaper to purchase.

This is a weird strawman and it has almost nothing to do the parent's claim. The guilded age is 1870-1890's.

I was replying to the bit I quoted?

Even if you had managed to come up with a point by selectively quoting the post, that would still be bad. The good-faith way to engage with somebody’s post is to reply to the meaning of the overall post. It might be necessary to cut some parts out for logical flow, but that shouldn’t change the meaning of what you are replying to.

Attacking a point by attacking its supporting points is a pretty standard way of going about arguing.

Sure, but not just by contradicting arbitrary sub-sentence snippets of text devoid of context. An attack against a supporting point should be related to the way that it supports the overall argument.

It’s fully the first half of the comment rather than a few words taken out of context

Reply on news.ycombinator.com