Hacker News Reader

Comment by johnisgood | Hacker News Reader

I do not like this in particular:

  stdin
        .byLine(KeepTerminator.yes)
        .uniq
        .map!(a => a.idup)
        .array
        .sort
        .copy(stdout.lockingTextWriter());

I would like to emphasize that this is a personal preference. No need to continue to bash me over it.

I prefer Elixir's |> operator, if you want an example of something I prefer.

View on HN

What’s the difference?

    stdin
      |> byLine(yes)
      |> uniq
      |> map(a => aidup)
      |> array
      |> sort
      |> copy(stdout)

I’m sorry if you took it as bashing. It’s mere curiosity as I’ve never seen that preference before.

Is it a fair comparison? Would it work in Elixir? I have not seen it in Elixir projects as such.

Adjusting for the actual Elixir functions, yes that would work. That's how Elixir's |> works, it takes the value from the left and passes it as the first argument to function on the right. Which is what the chain of calls in D is doing.

Thanks. I don’t know elixir.

I have not yet seen such long chains in Elixir. Could you show me a project where it is used?

"map(a => aidup)" caught me by surprise, too. Would Elixir do such a thing?

For what it's worth, in Elixir you might write something along the lines of the following (this is a rough translation, I haven't tested it):

  IO.stream(:stdio, :line)
  |> Stream.map(&String.trim_trailing/1)
  |> Enum.uniq()
  |> Enum.map(&String.duplicate(&1, 1))
  |> Enum.sort()
  |> Enum.each(&IO.puts/1)

This is not equivalent in style or presentation to:

  stdin
      .byLine(KeepTerminator.yes)
      .uniq
      .map!(a => a.idup)
      .array
      .sort
      .copy(stdout.lockingTextWriter());

Personally, I find the D version visually unappealing (and confusing), especially the way "stdin" sits alone on its own line, followed by a sequence of indented method calls. The excessive use of dots combined with the indentation structure makes it look, to me, rather awkward.

That is just my own opinion.

You can format it whatever way you like. D does not use formatting to impose semantic meaning.

And yet... Perl is good with its chained operators acting on lists?

    print join '',
        sort { $a cmp $b }
        grep { !$seen{$_}++ } # = uniq
        <STDIN>;

I do not write such Perl code, but I have in the past.

Oh and by the way, it does not look that different from that of Rust. :) I have came across a lot of Rust projects.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com