Hacker News Reader

scoop, Choco, and winget are all very different. winget is closest to Choco in that it prefers to just run regular installers. It keeps its own state of installed packages, though, while winget uses the same sources of truth as "Add/Remove programs" (msstore/appx and the "uninstall" group in the registry). Scoop is its own thing that installs everything under its own prefix and manages its own state.

View on HN

>winget uses the same sources of truth as "Add/Remove programs" (msstore/appx and the "uninstall" group in the registry).

I find that behavior incredibly annoying. I mainly use Chocolatey, so every once in a while when a package is heavily outdated or missing from the repo I end up using Winget instead for convenience's sake. That means Winget keeps trying to update or manage Chocolatey packages, and as far as I know, there's no easy way to stop that.

The thing about Chocolatey is that, iirc, it’s still largely community members maintaining that registry. Not the best in a cybersecurity context, and some firms may have licensing against unauthorized distribution of their installer files like that.

Hence WinGet, a Microsoft owned and operated alternative that those firms may feel less jittery about.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com