Hacker News Reader

Comment by jmmcd | Hacker News Reader

> The fact that AI can do your homework should tell you how much your homework is worth.

A lot of people who say this kind of thing have, frankly, a very shallow view of what homework is. A lot of homework can be easily done by AI, or by a calculator, or by Wikipedia, or by looking up the textbook. That doesn't invalidate it as homework at all. We're trying to scaffold skills in your brain. It also didn't invalidate it as assessment in the past, because (eg) small kids don't have calculators, and (eg) kids who learn to look up the textbook are learning multiple skills in addition to the knowledge they're looking up. But things have changed now.

View on HN

Completely agree - I always thought the framing of "exercises" is the right one, the point is that your brain grows by doing. It's been possible for a long time to e.g. google a similar algebra problem and find a very relevant math stackexchange post, doesn't mean the exercises were useless.

"The fact that forklift truck can lift over 500kg should tell you how worthwhile it is for me to go to a gym and lift 100kg." - complete non-sequitur.

If the judge of your fitness took into account only the amount you could lift, then sure, why not use a forklift.

This is what's happened in education. The education system is not concerned with teaching you to learn, or even teaching you, it's concerned with grades.

As many have stated here, homework is practice for the student, and can be helpful in learning. However, it's given out as something to grade without any collaboration on the learning experience.

By the way, I'm ranting about all this as someone who did very well in both high-school and university, so I feel somewhat justified in calling bullshit on the whole thing.

> A lot of homework can be easily done by AI

Then maybe the homework assignment has been poorly chosen. I like how the article's author has decided to focus on the process and not the product and I think that's probably a good move.

I remember one of my kids' math teachers talked about wanting to switch to in inverted classroom. The kids would be asked to read a some part of their textbook as homework and then they would work through exercise sheets in class. To me, that seemed like a better way to teach math.

> But things have changed now.

Yep. Students are using AIs to do their homework and teachers are using AIs to grade.

Yep, making time to sit down to do homework, forming an understanding of planning the doing part, forming good habits of doing them, knowing how to look up stuff, in a book index or on Wikipedia or by searching or asking AI. The expectation is still that some kind of text output needs to be found and then read, digested.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com